Debussy’s reception in England

In 1908-9, Claude Debussy made two appearances conducting his own works in England.  The Musical Times reported on the occasions.

The report on the first concert:

Nothing could have been heartier than the applause which greeted M. Claude Debussy as he stepped on to the platform at Queen’s Hall on February 1.  The warmth of the welcome which he received testified to the esteem in which he is held in this country.  The occasion was a concert of the Queen’s Hall Orchestra, which thereby became invested with unusual interest.  That exquisite little tone-poem, “L’après-midi d’fun faune” was the first piece which M. Debussy conducted.  This characteristic work, which has become familiar to London and provincial concert-goers, received a delicate and impressive rendering under the baton of its composer.  As a conductor M. Debussy is undemonstrative; he has nothing to do with those gesture demonstrations adopted by some wielders of the baton, yet he gets what he wants from the players who interpret his music.

The novelty of the afternoon’s music was “La Mer”, three symphonic sketches for orchestra. …

So novel are the effects which M. Debussy obtains from his wonderful scheme of orchestral colour, so elusive is the music, so formless, and yet in a way so graphic, that it is difficult to express an opinion upon a work of this kind after a first hearing.  Such atmospheric strains, so unlike what one is accustomed to, must be listened to in a passive frame of mind, perchance in a darkened room.  There can be no question as to the cleverness of the music or its poetic import; the only thing is to get one’s ears educated, so to speak, in order to appreciate its strange idiom.  At the close of the performance the composer-conductor – who appeared in the unconventional garb of a lounge jacket, Why not? – was most enthusiastically recalled. (1)

The following year, Debussy returned to conduct his three Nocturnes (“Nuages”, “Fêtes”, and “Sirènes”) and L’apriès-midi d’fun faune.  This performance, however, was not without incident.  Sir Henry Woods had rehearsed the orchestra, and rehearsal had gone smoothly.  However, in the concert, the orchestra “fell apart” in the second Nocturne.  The Musical Times reported that “disaster seemed imminent, and M. Debussy was disposed to stop, but the band went on resolutely and happily recovered.” (2)  Henry Woods recalled:

In the second movement of the Nocturnes [“Fêtes”]… the times changes a good deal.  To the surprise of all of us, Debussy (who, quite candidly, was not a good conductor even of his own works) suddenly lost his head, and his beat!  Realizing what he had done, he evidently felt the best thing was to stop and begin the movement over again.  He tapped the desk, and tapped again.

Then the most extraordinary thing happened.  The orchestra refused to stop.  It really was an amazing situation.  Here was a famous composer directing a work of his own and, having got into difficulties, he was asking the orchestra to stop and was being met with refusal.  They obviously did not intend to stop; they knew that the audience would think that the fault was theirs.  Moreover, the work (which they liked immensely) was going beautifully and they meant to give a first-rate performance of it: which they proceeded to do and succeeded in doing.  I never knew them more unanimous. 

The audience by no means missed the fact that something had gone wrong because it was so evident that he had tried to stop the orchestra.  At the end, in truly English fashion, they recorded their appreciation to such an extent that he was compelled to repeat the movement.  This time nothing went wrong and the ovation was even greater than before.  Debussy was nonplussed and certainly did not understand the English mind; but I was proud of my orchestra that afternoon and had the satisfaction of seeing that he had been proud to conduct it. (3)

The Musical Times reported that:

The Debussy cult is making great progress in this country.  It has reached that interesting stage when many people who are really desperately bewildered, affect to perceive beauties and wonderful meanings that have probably entirely escaped the composer.  But there is no mistaking the depth and width of the influence Debussy is exerting on the art.  His music may be classed as nebulous, fragile, diaphanous, and so on, but one cannot resist the langour of the hazy atmosphere with which it envelops and mesmerises the listener.  What one appears to miss is the attribute and strength and grip and clearness of purpose.  It is nearly always veiled suggestion and an appeal to imaginativeness.  (4)

(1) Musical Times, 1908.  Cited in: Scholes, Percy (1947) The Mirror of Music.  London: Novello and Company, vol. 1,  p.449-450.
(2) Musical Times, April 1909.  Cited in: op. cit., p. 450.
(3) Sir Henry Wood, My Life of Music, p. 298.  Cited in: op. cit.
(4) Musical Times, April 1909.  Cited in: op. cit.


Featured Content

Stokowski playing Bach on the organ
Stewart Warkov, assistant manager of the Symphony of The Air in 1961 described Stokowski playing Bach on the organ: Stokowski played Bach on the organ for me, each time one of the great pieces he had arranged. The sound, the phrasing, and the registration, the ritards and the accelerandos, gave me the impression of hearing […]
Look under your feet
The lesson which life constantly repeats is to ‘look under your feet.’You are always nearer to the divine and the true sources of your power than you think.The lure of the distant and the difficult is deceptive.The great opportunity is where you are.Do not despise your own place and hour.Every place is under the stars.Every […]
Learn my name
Stokowski’s ability to inspire musicians was sometimes balanced by the ability to turn them off.  Saidenberg altered me to a remarkable violinist who quit the Philadelphia Orchestra and went on to become America’s greatest authority on constitutional law.  “Raoul Berger was a wonderful violinist in the Philadelphia Orchestra.  One day at rehearsal, Stoki stopped the […]
Schoenberg’s composition class
An account of Arnold Schoenberg teaching a composition class: Well, first of all there was composition class, in which he analyzed in brief the first sections of several Schubert sonatas. How he adores Schubert! “Many people say,” he remarked, “that Schubert is too long. He is long-yes-but for me he is always too short!” Such […]
Sight singing with Handel
When Handel travelled through Chester, on his way to Ireland, this year, 1741 (to give the first performance of Messiah), I was at the Public School in that city and very well remember seeing him [Handel] smoke a pipe, over a dish of coffee, at the Exchange Coffee House; for being extremely curious to see […]
Skye Boat Song
Title: Skye Boat Song Composer: Scottish folk melody (arr. Greg Smith) Instrumentation: Piano Product medium: PDF score
Entertaining to educate
“I would rather entertain and hope that people learned something than educate people and hope they were entertained.” — Walt Disney L. Howes, “20 Lessons from Walt Disney on Entrepreneurship, Innovation and Chasing Your Dreams”, Forbes, 17 July 2012, https://www.forbes.com/sites/lewishowes/2012/07/17/20-business-quotes-and-lessons-from-walt-disney/?sh=4b3af9d44ba9.
Liszt on the piano
In its span of seven octaves [the piano] embraces the range of an orchestra; the ten fingers of a single man suffice to render the harmonies produced by the combined forces of more than 100 concerted instruments. We make arpeggios like the harp, prolonged notes like wind instruments, staccatos, and a thousand other effects which […]
A lesson with Beethoven
One fearful winter’s day in Vienna, in 1794, the snow standing deep and still falling fast, the traffic almost entirely suspended in the streets, Countess Teresa Brunswick, then a girl of fifteen, was waiting for Beethoven’s arrival, to give her her pianoforte lesson. Weather never stopped him; but when he appeared it was obvious that […]
Handel’s speedy method
Morrell gave Handel the words of Cleopatra’s air “Convey me to some peaceful shore” in Alexander Balus, he cried out “Damn your Iambics!”. Morell offered to change them to trochees and went into the next room to do so, only to find about three minutes later that Handel had set them as they stood.” Dean, […]