Schoenberg’s composition class

An account of Arnold Schoenberg teaching a composition class:

Well, first of all there was composition class, in which he analyzed in brief the first sections of several Schubert sonatas. How he adores Schubert! “Many people say,” he remarked, “that Schubert is too long. He is long-yes-but for me he is always too short!” Such was not the opinion, however, of Mr. E., who, when Uncle Arnold asked the class, after Mr. Stein’s rendition of the 1st movement of the D major Sonata, how they liked it, replied, “Well, it seems to me an awful lot of spinning out of not much!” “So?” queried le maître. “You think? Mr. Stein! PLAY IT AGAIN!” Talk about the rebuff royal! All during this performance he happily bobbed his head from side to side and danced about in a most outlandish manner, obviously enjoying himself tremendously. Then, at the end, he inquired, “Now did you find this very pleasant?” This time everyone assented, even the stubborn E., who, however, was not squelched even by this demonstration. Shortly afterwards, when S. was telling how, in contrast to Schubert’s love of repeating his motives and rhythms, his ideal has always been, at least since the first Kammersymphonie, to say as much as possible in the least possible room, E. was heard distinctly to mutter in the background, “Not in Gurre-Lieder!”

Newlin, Dika (1980) Diaries and Recollections, (1938-76). New York: Pendragon Press, p. 132.


Posted

in

by


Featured Content

Recollections from Gallipoli
Title: Recollections from Gallipoli Text: Ellis Salis Music: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Tenor and piano Product medium: PDF score Sample:
Bright Sunny Day
Title: Bright Sunny Day Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano Duet Level: Piano I – level I (5 finger position, left and right hands) Product medium: PDF score & MP3 accompaniment track (Audio sample of accompaniment track only)
The art of playing the triangle
George Plimpton, a writer and sportsman, asked if he could play in the New York Philharmonic for a month to write about the workings of an orchestra.  Leonard Bernstein assigned him to the percussion section.  The principal percussionist, Walter Rosenberg, recalled his experience: During rehearsals I would lean over and point to where we were […]
Out of practice
“All I have left is a long nose and a fourth finger out of practice.” Chopin, in Scotland, unable to visit his friend Julian in London because of ill health. Cited in: Zaluski, Iweo & Pamela (1993) The Scottish Autumn of Frederick Chopin. Edinburgh: John Donald Publishers, p.23.
It’s not hard work
“Talent labors, genius creates.” Florestan (one of Schumann’s characters) Robert Schumann,Gesammelte Schriften über Musik und Muisker  (Leipzig, 1854), IV.  Cited in Weiss, Piero & Taruskin, Richard (2008) Music in the Western World: A History in Documents.  California: Thomson, p. 306.
Blue Flemingo
Title: Blue Flemingo Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano Product medium: PDF score SAMPLE:
Hans Zimmer on the musical experience
Everybody tells you that the youth of today, whoever they are, have a short attention span, and you can’t give them anything decent. That’s complete crap. The youth of today, just like anyone else, like a good story and want to be transported, and to have an experience. They don’t want to be bored, so […]
Beethoven’s handwriting
Franz Xaver Schnyder von Wartensee (1786-1868) was a composer who wanted lessons with Beethoven.  Beethoven would only look at his compositions. Schnyder often dined in the Mehlgrube, because he knew that Beethoven often went there at the same time in the evening. One lovely spring night Schnyder, on entering the restaurant, saw his friend Beethoven […]
Abstraction XIII
Title: Abstraction XIII Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano Product medium: PDF score     Related products:     – Abstraction XIII (mp3)  
Air III
Title: Air III Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano Duet Level: Piano I – level 1 (five finger positions, left and right hands) Product medium: PDF score & MP3 accompaniment track (Audio sample of accompaniment track only)