Two hands or one

American pianist Seymour Lipkin, a student of Rudolf Serkin recalled a performance of Beethoven’s Hammerklavier Sonata

Back in the 1970s I gave a recital at Curtis at Mr. Serkin’s invitation.  I was playing the Hammerklavier in those years.  Why, in my right mind … I should never have … but I did.  There, sitting in the front row, was Serkin.  Now, that was tantamount to suicide to walk out and play the Hammerklavier with Rudolf Serkin under your nose.  Somehow I got through it.  In all my previous performances of the sonata I’d played the opening with two hands, as almost every pianist in the world does.  I hadn’t wanted to make a mess of it at the very beginning.  Moments before going on stage I had a fit of conscience.  “My god, Serkin’s sitting there; if he sees me play that with two hands, he’ll never forgive me.  He won’t speak to me for the rest of my life.”  I had never even practiced it with one hand.  But, I knew, it had to be all or nothing.  Da-dum!  And for the only time in my life I hit it absolutely perfectly.  Every performance thereafter, when I attempted it with one hand, I made a god-awful mess. He was so proud of me afterwards.  “Wonderful, with one hand! Courageous of you! Wonderful.” “Thank you, Mr. Serkin, I do it all the time.”

Cited in: Lehmann, Stephen (2003) Rudolf Serkin: A Life.  New York: Oxford University Press, p. 211-212.


Featured Content

Reverie II
Reverie II Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano (left hand) Product medium: PDF score
Forgive (Tchaikovsky)
Title: Forgive ( Прости!) (opus 60, no. 11] Composer: Pytor Il'yich Tchaikovsky (arr. Greg Smith) Instrumentation: Cello and piano Product medium: PDF score and part Sample:
On the Day I Called for Help – Psalm 137 (138)
Title: On the day I call for help Text: Psalm 137 (138): 1-3, 6-8. R. v.3 Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: SATB and piano Product medium: PDF score and part Sample:    
Never bore your listeners
Conductor and pianist Seymour Lipkin (born 1928) recalled piano lessons with his teacher, Bohemian-born pianist Rudolf Serkin: He said so many memorable things to me that I continue to pass on to my students.  A few examples: “The worst crime you can commit as an artist is to bore your listeners”; for another, “People who […]
An experiment in the colours of keys
The relativity of all these key-colour associations was illustrated during a debate on the whole subject organised in London in 1886 by the Journal “Musical Opinion”. That section of the audience that maintained the definite existence of “key colour” by which it could aurally identify a key was submitted to a test, a well known […]
Handel and the soprano
The great singer, Cuzzoni, refused to sing an air of his the way he wished it. He seized her, and, dragging her to a window, threatened to throw her out, thundering, “I always knew you were a devil, but I’ll show you that I am Beelzebub, the prince of devils.” Hughes, Rupert (2004) The Love […]
Just a few variations
Tchaikovsky was an enthusiastic student at the St. Petersberg Conservatoire.  Anton Rubinstein asked Tchaikvosky to write a series of contrapuntal variations on a given theme.  "I expected that he would present me with about a dozen.  But Tchaikovsky turned up the next class day with more than two hundred!" Cited in: Hanson, Lawrence and Elisabeth […]
Believe in Luck
“I am a great believer in luck and the harder I work the more of it I have.”— Stephen Leacock, Canadian author American Opinion, volume 2, issues 8-11, page 20
Life is green
“All theory is grey, but the precious tree of life is green.” Maurice Ravel to Hélène Jourdan-Morhange, describing Schoenberg’s intellectualism.  Hélène Jourdan-Morhange, Ravel et nous (Geneva, 1945), p. 104.  Cited in:  Nichols, Roger (1987) Ravel Remembered.  London: Faber & Faber., p. 61.
A very specific error indeed
The following is an account of the conductor Hans von Bülow: The newspaper critics Bülow continued to despise because of their self-importance, and he lost no opportunity to expose their musical ignorance.  On one occasion, Bülow, at a public rehearsal in the Philharmonie, remarked upon a printing error in the second horn part of the […]