This music is too hard

In 1862 Brahms went to Vienna:

Although he been in Vienna only a few weeks, Brahms was already making a name for himself.  After the first performance of  his First Serenade, Hanslick wrote more favorably, calling the work “one of the most charming of modern compositions.”

A few months later, the leading Viennese orchestra played the Second Serenade.  Though this was even better liked than the First, it caused a minor riot in the orchestra.  The musicians complained that the work was much too difficult.  At the final rehearsal, a clarinetist rose suddenly from his seat.

“This music is no good to play,” he said defiantly.  And a number of other nodded their agreement.

Concertmaster Hellmesberger looked around in high indignation.  The conductor, who was one of Hellmesberger’s friends, rapped sharply with his baton.  “”Gentlemen, gentlemen, what does this mean?” He fixed the clarinetist with a stern eye.  “Am I the leader of this orchestra, or are you?”

The rebellious player still stood his ground.  Conductor Dessoff laid down his baton and stepped from the podium. “Very well, then, I resign.”

“And I too,” cried Hellmesberger.

“And I,” echoes the first flute player.

Listening from the back of the hall, Brahms shivered in his seat.  The situation threatened to become serious.  However, the firm stand of Dessoff and Hellmesberger eventually convinced the men that they had better go on.

The final performance of the Serenade was such a success that the players forgot their resentment over its difficulties.

Source: Goss, Madeleine & Schauffler, Robert (1943) Brahms The Master. New York: Henry Holt and Company, p.182-183.

Posted

in

by


Featured Content

Bernstein’s Workroom
Leonard Bernstein’s children have donated the contents of his main composing studio to Indiana University.   The contents include “Bernstein’s stand-up composing table; a conducting stool that may have been used by Brahms, given as a gift by the Vienna Philharmonic; an electric pencil sharpener; a telephone; an ashtray and disposable lighters; Grammy-nomination plaques; and […]
Never use a score
I never use a score when conducting my orchestra. Does a lion tamer enter a cage with a book on how to tame a lion? — Dimitri Mitropoulos, conductor Zographos, Achilleas (2017) Music and Chess. Milford: Russell Enterprises Inc.
Music as a means of common meditation
“There is also in this music an extraordinary sense of control over the passage of time; a moment will be held still as if suspended, and then released, with a rush.  Einstein has told us that time is relative, flexible and elastic; I have noticed these qualities whenever I have tried to play to the […]
Music in the very heart of noise
I frequently hear music in the very heart of noise. — George Gerswhin Goldberg, Isaac, and Garson, Edith. George Gershwin: A Study in American Music. United Kingdom, F. Ungar Publishing Company, 1958, p.139.
Bunking down in the Philharmonic
Cellist Gregor Piatigorsky, after running into some problems with his accommodation, was spending a cold November day in the Tiergarten, Berlin, in 1923. Throughout the course of the day, he was approached by Paul Bose to play Schoenberg’s Pierrot Lunaire. It began to rain. In Moscow it probably is snowing now, I thought absently, making […]
Music as a metaphor … or not
“Most music is metaphor, but Wolff is not. I am not metaphor either. Parable, maybe. Cage is sermon.” – Morton Feldman, American composer Cited in Tom Johnson, Remembrance, September 1987. Accessed 11 May 2013.
Waste not, want not
While attending school in Lüneberg, J. S. Bach used to travel to Hamburg (50km away) to hear the organist of the Catharinekirche: J. A. Reincken.  Marpurg describes how Bach, returning almost penniless to Lüneberg, once rested outside an inn; how someone threw two herring heads out on the rubbish heap; how Bach – a Thuringian, to […]
From the heart
“What comes from the heart, goes to the heart.” — Samuel Coleridge Taylor, English poet, critic and philosopher. Coleridge, Samuel (1856) Seven Lectures on Shakespeare and Milton. London: Chapman and Hall, page xlv
The musical memory
“Of course, almost anybody can memorize things, especially music. It’s like the ABCs and, for most, fun to do. I’ve taught music in middle school programs and have been surprised at the hefty repertoires of popular music that 12- to 16- year olds commit to memory. To boot, they knew when I made a mistake […]
Half a sonata
Sergei Prokofiev was once asked to give a piano recital. He declined, offering this explanation: “It would cost me half a sonata.” Source: Samuel, Prokofiev