Steering the audience’s taste

The following advice appeared in the British Journal the Musical Times in January 1879:

A young student wishes us to tell him what to do under the following circumstances: He has been carefully educated in music, for which he has considerable aptitude and an intense love; he is an efficient pianist, and knows most of the classical works; but when he goes amongst his friends and plays what he has studied, he is requested to "give them something pretty", as they have no desire to be made miserable or to be sent to sleep … We should counsel him to make the best of it, and by all means rather to assert his own intellectual musical position than to suffer himself to be brought down to the level of theirs.  We remember hearing of a very clever, but firm and resolute man who said that whenever he found that anything did not agree with him, he continued taking it until it did.  Some such principle as this has guided the directors of the Monday Popular Concerts.  At first, we can vouch from our own experience, many of the audience went to sleep; then they began to be a little ashamed of this; because so many of their friends kept awake; gradually they succeeded not only in keeping their eyes but their ears open; and this point gained, victory was certain, for those who were not conquered were taken prisoners.  Let our student profit by this example, and remembering that he has a mission rather to instruct than amuse, select such pieces for performance as will lead his audience by degrees to appreciation of the best works. He will find that only two or three will listen at first; but if he persevere, and, above all, have patience to wait, he may rest satisfied that the rest will follow their example.


Cited in: Scholes, Percy (1947) The Mirror of Music: 1844-1944.  London: Novello, p. 307.


Posted

in

by


Featured Content

Musing by Moonlight
Title: Musing by Moonlight Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano Duet Level: Piano I – level I (5 finger position, left and right hands) Product medium: PDF score & MP3 accompaniment track (Audio sample of accompaniment track only)
Content of art
How can you expect a beholder to experience my picture as I experienced it? A picture comes to me a long time beforehand; who knows how long a time beforehand, I sensed, saw, and painted it and yet the next day even I do not understand what I have done. How can anyone penetrate my […]
Finding the voice of Piazzolla
I was writing symphonies, chamber music, string quartets. But when Nadia Boulanger analyzed my music, she complained that she couldn’t find any Piazzolla in there. She could find Ravel and Stravinsky, maybe Bela Bartok or Hindemith, but never Piazzolla. The truth is I was ashamed to tell her that I was a tango musician, that […]
On thinking
“If you make people think they’re thinking they’ll love you: but if you really make them think, they’ll hate you.” Don Marquis, American writer, poet & artist. Creator of the characters such as Archy (1916), a cockroach who had been a poet in a previous life, who supposedly left poems on Marquis’ typewriter by jumping […]
Julius Asal on interpretation
On the one hand, I believe that to connect tradition and innovation is the most important thing to me personally. On the other hand, to explore the score and be close to what the composer wanted is essential. There is a way to find your own language within the details that the composers left. Julius […]
The political function of music
“There can be no music without an idealogy. The old composers, whether they knew it or not, were upholding a political theory. Most of them, of course, were bolstering the rule of the upper classes. Only Beethoven was a forerunner of the revolutionary movement.” – Dmitry Shostakovich Cited in: Nettl, Paul (1969) The Book of […]
The art of listening
“It’s a challenge, for me at least, to do nothing but listen.  You need to set aside time for it.  You need to concentrate on the music alone (and not on your next deadline).  But when it works, you open yourself up to the transcendent ecstasy good music can bring.” Francis Merson, editor, Limelight, April […]
Motion and art
“The statue is concentrated in one moment of perfection. The image stained upon the canvas posses no spiritual element of growth or change. If they know nothing of death, it is because they know nothing of life, for the secrets of life and death belong to those, and those only, whom the sequence of time […]
Music and time
“There is also in this [nineteenth-century romantic] music an extraordinary sense of control over the passage of time; a moment will be held still as if suspended, and then released with a rush. Einstein has told us that time is relative, flexible and elastic; I have noticed these qualities whenever I have tried to play […]
Claudio Arrau in Newcastle
While the Century Theatre in Broadmeadow (Australia) primarily operated as a cinema, it was also hosted concerts, including by the Sydney Symphony Orchestra. On one occasion, Claudio Arrau performed in the theatre, as recalled by Harry Armstrong: With only a few minutes to go before the famous pianist was scheduled to commence his performance, which […]