Steering the audience’s taste

The following advice appeared in the British Journal the Musical Times in January 1879:

A young student wishes us to tell him what to do under the following circumstances: He has been carefully educated in music, for which he has considerable aptitude and an intense love; he is an efficient pianist, and knows most of the classical works; but when he goes amongst his friends and plays what he has studied, he is requested to "give them something pretty", as they have no desire to be made miserable or to be sent to sleep … We should counsel him to make the best of it, and by all means rather to assert his own intellectual musical position than to suffer himself to be brought down to the level of theirs.  We remember hearing of a very clever, but firm and resolute man who said that whenever he found that anything did not agree with him, he continued taking it until it did.  Some such principle as this has guided the directors of the Monday Popular Concerts.  At first, we can vouch from our own experience, many of the audience went to sleep; then they began to be a little ashamed of this; because so many of their friends kept awake; gradually they succeeded not only in keeping their eyes but their ears open; and this point gained, victory was certain, for those who were not conquered were taken prisoners.  Let our student profit by this example, and remembering that he has a mission rather to instruct than amuse, select such pieces for performance as will lead his audience by degrees to appreciation of the best works. He will find that only two or three will listen at first; but if he persevere, and, above all, have patience to wait, he may rest satisfied that the rest will follow their example.


Cited in: Scholes, Percy (1947) The Mirror of Music: 1844-1944London: Novello, p. 307.


Posted

in

by


Featured Content

Playing by the mood of the audience
Rachmaninoff sent fellow composer/pianist Medtner his Corelli Variations.  He wrote: I played them here about fifteen times, but of these fifteen performances, only one was good.  The others were sloppy.  I can't play my own compositions!  And it's so boring! Not once have I played these all in continuity.  I was guided by the coughing […]
Oration XIV (St. Gregory the Theologian)
Title: Oration XIV Text: St. Gregory the Theologian Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: SATB and piano Product medium: PDF score Samples:
The Anecdote to Distraction is Art
“If you are on a mission to discover what you have to offer, and to bring it out into the world, every moment you spend distracted is a moment you aren’t following your art. It’s a moment you aren’t pursuing your true potential.” — David Kadavy David Kadavy, “The Anecdote to Distraction is Art”, https://steemit.com/productivity/@kadavy/the-antidote-to-distraction-is-art-1515195404-5002096. […]
Difficult music is the easiest to play
Scriabin’s fiery D#-minor Etude, with its relentless triplets and huge leaps, used to just fall under my fingers, while the Lento final movement of the Copland Sonata was a minefield of wrong notes. Why is that? Is it just because we practice hard music 20 times as much as easy music, or is it psychological, […]
Lord, Heal My Soul – Psalm 40 (41)
TITLE: Lord, Heal My Soul TEXT: Psalm 40 (41): 2-5, 13-14. R. v.5 COMPOSER: Greg Smith INSTRUMENTATION: SATB and piano SAMPLE:  
Luther on music
“I am not satisfied with any man who despises music. For music is a gift of God. It will drive away the devil, and makes people cheerful. Occupied with it, man forgets all anger, unchastity, pride, and other vices. Next to theology, I give music the next place and highest praise.” – Martin Luther Cited […]
Your Words, Lord, are Spirit and Life – Psalm 18 (19)
TITLE: Your Words, Lord, are Spirit and Life TEXT: Psalm 18 (19): 8-10, 15 COMPOSER: Greg Smith INSTRUMENTATION: SATB and piano PRODUCT MEDIUM: PDF score and part SAMPLE:
A very specific error indeed
The following is an account of the conductor Hans von Bülow: The newspaper critics Bülow continued to despise because of their self-importance, and he lost no opportunity to expose their musical ignorance.  On one occasion, Bülow, at a public rehearsal in the Philharmonie, remarked upon a printing error in the second horn part of the […]
Vladimir Horowitz on encores
”You see,” he said, ”I have a very substantial program, and after a substantial program, you can’t play a substantial encore. You play a little … ” at this, he strummed the air with his fingers, tinkling an imaginary piano. ”It is,” he said, ”anticlimactic.” Clyde Haberman, “3,500 Japanese Applaud Horowtiz for 14 Minutes”, The […]
Application of talent
“…all talent, all application will not suffice if one’s whole life is not directed towards being a mediator of great thoughts and feelings. Every deed, yes, every thought leaves its trace on the personality. One must live a life of purity in every detail, even down to the morsel one is putting into one’s mouth. […]