Schoenberg’s composition class

An account of Arnold Schoenberg teaching a composition class:

Well, first of all there was composition class, in which he analyzed in brief the first sections of several Schubert sonatas. How he adores Schubert! “Many people say,” he remarked, “that Schubert is too long. He is long-yes-but for me he is always too short!” Such was not the opinion, however, of Mr. E., who, when Uncle Arnold asked the class, after Mr. Stein’s rendition of the 1st movement of the D major Sonata, how they liked it, replied, “Well, it seems to me an awful lot of spinning out of not much!” “So?” queried le maître. “You think? Mr. Stein! PLAY IT AGAIN!” Talk about the rebuff royal! All during this performance he happily bobbed his head from side to side and danced about in a most outlandish manner, obviously enjoying himself tremendously. Then, at the end, he inquired, “Now did you find this very pleasant?” This time everyone assented, even the stubborn E., who, however, was not squelched even by this demonstration. Shortly afterwards, when S. was telling how, in contrast to Schubert’s love of repeating his motives and rhythms, his ideal has always been, at least since the first Kammersymphonie, to say as much as possible in the least possible room, E. was heard distinctly to mutter in the background, “Not in Gurre-Lieder!”

Newlin, Dika (1980) Diaries and Recollections, (1938-76). New York: Pendragon Press, p. 132.


Posted

in

by


Featured Content

Here I Am, Lord – Psalm 39 (40)
Title: Here I Am, Lord Text: Psalm 39 (40): 2, 4, 7-1.  R. vv.8-9 Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: SATB and piano Product medium: PDF score and part SAMPLE:    
Beethoven on music
“Music is the mediator between the spiritual and the sensual life.  Although the spirit be not master of that which it creates through music, yet it is blessed in this creation, which, like every creation of art, is mightier than the artist. — Beethoven Edwards, Tyron (1891) A Dictionary of Thoughts.  New York: Cassell Publishing […]
Positive change through creativity
You need something like Sesame Street to sort of increase the volume of good in the world. And also to know that through creativity, you can make change. Positive change can occur if you’re willing to see a problem and try to fix it and do it creatively. — Trevor Crafts Steve Rose, “The Secret […]
The effect of audience reception on Stravinsky’s compositional process
Stravinksy on the public not particularly liking his music: Their attitude certainly cannot make me deviate from my path. I shall assuredly not sacrifice my predilections and my aspirations to the demands of those who, in their blindness, do not realize that they are simply asking me to go backwards … I could not follow […]
Hilary Hahn on technique, practise mentality, and performance
Violinist Hilary Hahn on practice and technique: I’ve always worked hard at my technique … But I’ve worked hard at my musicality as well. When I was doing my etudes my teachers always made sure I didn’t go onto the next until I had the first really good. But it wasn’t good unless it was […]
Try, try, try
“Try, try, try, and keep on trying is the rule that must be followed to become an expert in anything.” – W. Clement Stone, American businessman
Review of Pablo Casals
A Review written in El Alcance of the cellist Pablo Cassals: His bow, sometimes sweet as a voice from heaven, at other times vibrant and robust, produces such a sonorous combination of voices and tones that it seems that the body of his violincello is the magic secret of sublime harmonies capriciously transformed at the […]
Diderot on good music
“Good music is very close to primitive language.” Denis Diderot (Elements of Physiology, 1875)
The Queen Stands at Your Right Hand (piano)
Title: The Queen Stands At Your Right Hand Text: Psalm 44 (45): 10-12. 16 Composer: Greg Smith Instrumentation: Piano Product medium: PDF score     Related products:     – The Queen Stands At Your Right Hand – Piano solo (mp3 recording)     – The Queen Stands At Your Right Hand – SATB and piano (score) Sample:
Quotes
QUICK LINKS: Audience reception Composers General Performance practice Performers Style Symbolism Teaching methods The creative process The experience of art The purpose of the arts Work ethic Works See also: ANECDOTES AUDIENCE RECEPTION Quick links COMPOSERS Quick links GENERAL Quick links PERFORMANCE PRACTICE Quick links PERFORMERS Quick links STYLE Quick links SYMBOLISM Quick links TEACHING […]